Tom Magnuson down by the river
Reedy Fork Creek or as some say river
“I could still get across here, ” said Tom Magnuson, whose hobby is finding traces of long-abandoned roads in North Carolina, dating to Colonial times, “but the water would slow you and make you a target for a long time.”
He was projecting himself back 226 years when British soldiers were indeed targets as they forded Reedy Fork Creek, which as it flows through north central Guilford County off N.C. 61, looks like a river.
Magnuson was leading a tour of the Trading Path Association, a non-profit group that he operates from his home in Hillsborough. Each first Sunday of the month, he leads members and anyone who wants to tag along on a hike to places where he has found evidence of 18th and 19th century roads. Where he finds them he usually finds fords. He says roads in those days didn’t lead from one settlement to another but from one ford to another.
People, he said, measured a journey by the time they would get to the fords. For example, a trip from what’s now the historic town of Hillsborough to Charlotte took six to seven days. The Deep River was forded at Jamestown. The Yadkin River had several fording possibilities.
Another fording place was known during the Revolutionary War as Weitzel’s Mill Ford (sometime spelled with two ls) It had three fords. The mill used one, the public crossed the water on another and cattle and horses forded on a third.
It was here on March 6, 1781, in a battle – not a skirmish, Magnuson insists – British and Americans clashed in a prelude to the Battle of Guilford Courthouse, which would be fought on March 15.
Each side would suffer casualties at Weitzel’s. The British put a hurting on a group of militiamen from Virginia , South Carolina and Georgia. The militiamen occupied the south side of the stream to slow the British from reaching and crossing the ford. That gave the Americans, one of whose commanders was Col. Lighthorse Harry Lee (father of Robert E. Lee) , time to ford the stream. On the other side, they fortified themselves in the mill beside the creek and in a school house atop a hill overlooking the ford.
From the school house, the Americans picked off British as Red Coats crossed the mill ford. Earlier, the British successfully beat back the attempt by American militiamen to stop the Red Coats from reaching the ford.
The strategy worked for a while. At least 10 British were killed, some shot to death, others drowning. They had to tried to duck fire by veering off the ford. They wound up under water in the mill pond. After the Revolution, slaves working a second mill, Somers Mill, near the same ford, found remains of the British.
The British wised up, reassessed the situation and left the mill ford and sneaked across the creek – or river as some locals today call it – at the horse and cattle ford. They then opened fire on the American fortifications and forced a retreat.
The battle later had ramifications for both sides in the Battle of Guilford Courthouse. The British lost manpower and used ammunition at Weitzel’s Mill that were needed at the bigger battle.
American Gen. Nathanael Greene, in turn, was denied a strong militia force at Guilford Courthouse. The Virginia, Georgia and South Carolina militiamen became angry at Weitzel’s Mill. They felt they had been positioned to make them easy targets for the British. They suffered casualties. They decided to go home rather than join Greene forces and move toward Guilford Courthouse.
Their departure weakened Greene and led to his retreat at Guilford Courthouse, Magnuson says. Still, Greene’s forces inflicted heavy casualties on the British. Guilford Courthouse has been called a victory in defeat for the Americans. The British were so weakened they surrendered six months later at Yorktown.
Manguson believes, however, a Greene victory had been possible at Guilford Courthouse. It could have forced a British surrender there.
“I think this was the most important battles of the war,” Magnuson said as he went along the hillside that slopes from the old Somers house on the hill, built in about 1818 and now being restored.
Magnuson used the remains of one road bed to get down the river, where he tried to pinpoint other roads through the area. Road-like openings were obvious, but Magnuson wasn’t sure if they were roads or the remains of “races,” man-made streams that drew water into the mill and then released it back to Reedy Fork Creek.
A heavy rain didn’t stop him and about 20 followers from searching. Earlier that morning, before leaving home, he had studied maps and thought he was he knew where Weitzel’s Mill had stood and the location of the road that passed it.
“But then I was reading the maps again and I said, naw, I’m not so sure,” he said.
He has an idea of the school house’s site atop the hill, a spot that gave shooters an excellent view of the ford. But then again he says he’s not that sure. One way to find out would be through metal detectors. They would uncover lead from musket fire British marksmen fired at the building.
“I change my mind everyday,” Magnuson said. “There are so many possible explanations.”
Someone asked how Americans could aim effectively at British crossing the ford when so many trees saturate the hill?
Foliage would be an obstacle now, Magnuson replied, but not then.
“There would have been no wood here in the 18th century,” he said. “Wood was cut and used for everything.
Manguson would like academics to come study the battle site. He wishes Guilford Courthouse National Military Park would acquire the property. Both battles are closely related.
He can say for sure about the Weitzel’s Mill site that “a great deal of misery was created here,” he said.
(People who want to know more about Magnuson’s Trading Path Association can do so by calling 919 644-0600 or through info@tradingpath.org There’s also a web site, http://www.tradingpath.org)